Are you open to feedback? Tips on how to give feedback to dental hygiene students and patients effectively
Key Highlights
- Use constructive, respectful feedback to build dental hygiene students’ confidence and clinical skills.
- Apply the “feedback sandwich” to help students and patients accept corrections without feeling judged.
- Set achievable improvement goals, prioritize key corrections, and follow up to reinforce lasting progress.
Ask any dental hygienist about their memories of dental hygiene school, and you will hear stories of success and achievement along with self-doubt and stress. How each student perceived their academic journey was influenced by their faculty and how challenges were addressed.
In most cases, each of us encountered numerous “failures” or as one of my former coworkers called them, “first attempts in learning.” How we digested the feedback we received was measured, in part, by the amount of perspiration we exuded along with our determination to improve. Hopefully, our patient encounters allowed us to develop curiosity as well as hone our skills so that we would become the confident, skilled clinicians and dental educators we are today.
What made the environment one of acceptance and stimulation versus one of uneasiness and despair? In most cases, it was how feedback was presented to you. There are numerous ways for your faculty to provide guidance. In fact, no two approached you in the same way even if the circumstances were similar.
Various feedback techniques that work well
One approach was to work with you at your chair. This may be as simple as “What if we changed your chair position for better accessibility?” rather than, “You are sitting in the wrong place!” The former sounds much less demeaning and allows the student to adjust in the moment and not feel embarrassed.
A second approach is an actual demonstration. Asking the student to allow you to sit so you can illustrate a concept such as angulation or working stroke can be done so that the student can make improvements but not feel as though how they were working was inappropriate (especially if there is a patient in the chair).
Another method that works well is to ask a question. “What did you notice about the gingiva?” “Did you recall that certain medications may cause gingival inflammation? Let’s look and see if we notice any of those medications in your patient’s medical history.”
This can be a gentle way to reinforce the connection between other body systems and the oral cavity.
A reminder that we all need to hear is that it is a clever idea to “sandwich” feedback. In other words, start with a positive observation, follow with the comment, correction, or suggestion, and end with another positive.
An example might be: “I see you are removing heavy calculus from Mrs. Smith’s lower anterior teeth, and it’s looking great. I might suggest you use the ultrasonic to scale for the heavier deposits before you start with hand instrumentation. Once you have debrided that area, use your hand instruments that you have skillfully demonstrated and remove the remaining deposits.”
How to give effective feedback to patients
This approach to providing feedback can be applied to working with patients as well. If you remember, most of us were taught to brush and floss at a young age. By the time we reach adulthood, it is expected, perhaps erroneously, that we are skilled at brushing and flossing when, in fact, memories of that demonstration are long gone.
Many patients may find it uncomfortable to ask to be “shown” how to brush or floss properly. It is not uncommon for patients to share that one of the things that bothers them the most at a dental appointment is to be chastised for not flossing daily or brushing properly.
Rather than putting them in that position, you can use the sandwich method here as well. It might sound something like this: “Mrs. Peterson, I can see that you are brushing, and we know how important that is to maintain health. A suggestion I might add is to angle your brush a bit more like this. We call it the Bass technique, and most dental hygienists are taught to share this with patients so that we remove the most amount of plaque each time we brush. May I demonstrate that for you? Let’s plan to do a plaque score next visit to see if this is helpful to you.”
Related: 5 common patient misunderstandings and how dental hygienists can prevent them
I read that feedback should be less like an abrupt extraction and more like polishing where you are gently removing the outer coating, revealing something better underneath. The goal is that you are teaching critical thinking and evaluation. For patients, providing feedback should build confidence and trust in both you (the provider) and them. Those skills cannot develop in an environment of fear, judgement, and angst.
A simple formula would be to observe the behavior or skill first. If you need to interject, do so without negativity. Explain the concern whether it be safety, efficacy, or patient comfort.
It is important to be genuine. In the case of student interaction, when the comment needs to be more specific or if the error was more egregious, then a more personal conversation should be had. This can take place when the patient has been dismissed, or you can ask the student to step out and have the conversation away from others. If you are working directly with a patient, take time to listen and share information throughout the appointment, allowing time for questions and demonstrations as appropriate.
Choose the correction. If there are many infractions or adjustments, focus on the most useful correction first. You can address the others in another session. Don’t overwhelm students or patients with too much information at one time. People need time to digest new information before it becomes a habit.
Make a goal for improvement. As with all goals, it should be measurable and achievable. An example might be that the student begins on the lower anterior teeth and spends a minimum of 10 minutes in that area and then asks for a faculty check before moving on.
For a patient, maybe the goal is to have them floss every Sunday night in an effort to introduce the skill slowly and build to a more efficacious, daily habit down the road. If they return and state that they are only flossing once per week, praise that, reinforce the need to build on that success, and set a new goal that is achievable.
Finally, there needs to be follow-up. Did the student adhere to the goals set? If achieved, faculty can make a note in the student’s progress report that the issue has been addressed, and no further action is required at this point. In our other example, the patient can be evaluated by reduced plaque scores.
Great teachers are those who allow for individual growth. It is said that people are like popcorn kernels in oil. Most will pop, but not at the same time. Allow them to pop and provide the setting for that to occur.
The last word
We have all been there. Faculty still needs to reinforce the line between instructor and student, but remember, students are more likely to stay curious, recover from errors, and keep improving if we combine candor with kindness. The same applies to patients. The best practice-builder is often not only the treatment of teeth but treatment of the people we are privileged to care for.
Editor’s note: This article first appeared in RDH eVillage newsletter, a publication of the Endeavor Business Media Dental Group. Read more articles and subscribe.
About the Author
Diane Paz, DrBH, MEd, BS, RDHDiane Paz, DrBH, MEd, BS, RDH
Diane Paz, DrBH, MEd, RDH, is a retired assistant professor from AT Still University, Arizona School of Dental and Oral Health, in Mesa, Arizona. She currently teaches in both the dental hygiene and dental assisting programs at Mohave College online and clinically for Westmoreland County Community College in Youngwood, Pennsylvania. Diane can be reached at [email protected].
Related
Share knowledge with your patients and everyone will benefit.
dental_hygiene_instructor